For asylum seekers in Immigration Court, the Individual Hearing is where they tell their story to the judge and get a decision. Even with a kind Immigration Judge (IJ) and a reasonable DHS Attorney (prosecutor), testifying in court can be intimidating and stressful. Here, we'll talk about the Individual Hearing and what is expected from respondents (non-citizens seeking protection) and witnesses.

I've written before about what happens in Immigration Court, and it's helpful to have an idea about how things will proceed. Here, we'll focus more specifically on testimony.

Before we get to the testimony itself, let's talk a bit about preparing to testify. In most asylum cases, the respondent will submit a form I-589 and an affidavit, which is a written statement describing the events in your life and why you need asylum. It is important to review these documents before the Individual Hearing. In most cases, there are other documents to review as well: Notes from the Asylum Office or Credible Fear Interview, letters from witnesses, police documents, medical records, and country conditions evidence. In short, make sure to review any documents that you or DHS submitted to the court or Asylum Office, or that were produced by the U.S. government in your case. If your testimony is inconsistent with your affidavit or evidence, it could cause the IJ to conclude that you are not telling the truth, which would be bad news for your case.

It is also a good idea to practice before your court hearing. If you have a lawyer, the lawyer should assist with this. The practice sessions are a chance to make sure you are familiar with facts and dates, and that you can explain any problems or inconsistencies. It is also a chance for the lawyer to familiarize himself with your testimony and evidence. This is important, since cases are often prepared weeks in advance and it is easy to forget all the details.

In terms of the testimony, a few things to keep in mind: If you do not understand a question, say that you do not understand, and the questioner will repeat or rephrase their query. This is very common and you should not be afraid to say that you did not understand, since answering a question you misunderstood could lead you down a path that damages the case. If you do not know the answer or do not remember, do not guess. If you guess and your answer is different from other information in the record, or different from what your witness says, the IJ may think you are lying. Remember also that the government may have information about you, such as statements you made at prior interviews or on your visa application, and so if you do not remember what you said previously, it is better to say, "I don't know" than to guess and possibly get it wrong.

If you are using an interpreter, make sure to wait for the interpreter to complete their statement before you respond. Do not respond in English, even if you speak English. When you have an interpreter, judges can get annoyed if you respond in English or do not allow the interpreter to finish speaking. If you have a long answer, try to break it into pieces, so the interpreter can translate what you say and not forget anything.

In terms of the questioning, in most cases where you have a lawyer, your lawyer will ask you questions first and then the DHS attorney will ask questions. The IJ can jump in any time with questions (some judges ask more questions than others).

Your lawyer will typically go through your story during the direct examination. This is what you practice with the lawyer before court. After that, the DHS attorney can ask questions to probe credibility (whether you are telling the truth), and ask about inconsistencies in prior testimony or evidence, or implausible country condition information. The DHS attorney can also ask about any issues of concern, such as whether you filed for asylum on time, whether you have committed any crimes or engaged in terrorism-related activities, and whether your story is plausible (believable) in light of conditions in your country. Hopefully, you and your lawyer can anticipate these questions and you can be ready to answer them. The judge's questions are often similar to questions asked by DHS, but the judge is also thinking about her decision, and may be asking questions to support her anticipated conclusion.

In my experience, DHS attorneys and judges almost never ask trick questions. However, they sometimes ask confusing questions and they can occasionally be aggressive. Pay attention to the questions and do your best to answer. If you are not sure about the answer, say so. Keep your cool and if you need a break, ask for one.

For people without lawyers, the judge will often ask questions to determine whether you are eligible for relief. It is important to review your testimony and evidence in advance, and try to think about any areas of concern. This can be difficult, since some legal issues are not obvious to a non-lawyer. If you can get (i.e., pay for) a lawyer to at least evaluate your case and look for problems, that will help you prepare. Also, you might look for a free lawyer to assist you, though resources are very limited.

After you testify, your witnesses will have a turn. Normally, your lawyer questions the witness first, followed by DHS and the judge. Witnesses must wait outside the courtroom and will not hear the respondent's testimony. For this reason, it is important that they are familiar with what you will say and that they do not answer questions unless they actually know the answer.

A well-prepared respondent has a much greater chance for success in Immigration Court, so do your homework and make sure your witnesses do theirs. Hopefully, this will allow you to achieve a positive outcome in your case.

Originally posted on the Asylumist: www.Asylumist.com