There's a scene in the iconic 1994 movie Clerks where Dante Hicks says to his friend and fellow slacker Randall Graves: "You hate people!" Randall responds, "Yes, but I love social gatherings--isn't it ironic?" This is basically the opposite of my feelings towards the Asylum Office. The people are (mostly) great, but the organization is a disaster. Interviews are routinely delayed for years on end, decisions are delayed for months or years after that. The Asylum Offices rarely give sufficient notice before the interview, so there is little time to prepare, and the interviews themselves are often inefficient and interminably long.

In a recent post, I discussed Faiza W. Sayed's bold ideas for reforming the Asylum Office and reducing the backlog (which currently stands at well over 1.3 million cases). But the more I think about it, the more convinced I am that the Asylum Office cannot be saved. It should be eliminated.

Now don't get me wrong, I am not advocating for Asylum Officers to lose their jobs. Instead, I think they should be re-assigned to the DHS Office of the Principal Legal Advisor--the prosecutor's office in Immigration Court. Under this plan, anyone who files an asylum case would automatically be referred to court for adjudication. The additional people power (i.e., the Asylum Officers) would allow DHS to create a much more robust system to review asylum applications and determine which cases could be easily granted, either on the papers (without an interview) or with a very short interview. For cases that are not appropriate for a grant, the Asylum Officers (AOs) can help narrow issues so the cases can be more efficiently litigated before the Immigration Judge.

Why do I think this proposal would be any different from what we have now, where the Asylum Office interviews an applicant and either refers him to Immigration Court, denies the case where the person is in lawful status or grants asylum? There are several reasons.

First is speed. The Immigration Courts have been expanding at a break neck pace. While new cases are still coming in faster than pending cases are being resolved, the situation is improving. Five or ten years ago, it was common to wait two or three years or longer for a final hearing date. Today, most people in my part of the country wait between one and two years, and average wait times have been falling for the past couple years. While courts are hardly moving at light speed, they are certainly doing better than the Asylum Offices, where applicants often wait five or ten years for an interview.

Second, if the Asylum Officer Corp was rolled into DHS-OPLA, there is much that they could do to resolve cases in Immigration Court. After reviewing the asylum form and supporting documents, the AOs could decide whether the case should be granted or whether additional information is needed. If more information is needed, they could schedule the applicant for a short interview or request additional documentation. If the case is complicated, too time consuming or not amenable to a grant, the AOs can simply pass the case on to the DHS-OPLA attorney to litigate in court. But if an AO can resolve a case, that would save precious court time and DHS resources.

Even if they cannot completely resolve a case, AOs can narrow the issues for Immigration Court. For example, in some cases, the applicant has a well-founded fear of future persecution and is thus eligible for protection, but a bar to asylum might apply. Maybe the person did not file within one year of arrival, or the person was firmly resettled in a third country, or maybe a criminal bar applies. In those cases, DHS could agree that the person will receive protection and the only issue for the court is whether she will receive asylum or some lesser form of relief (Withholding of Removal or protection under the Torture Convention). Narrowing the issues in a case saves time for the judge and DHS, and also reduces stress and uncertainty for the asylum seeker.

AOs would also be very helpful in cases where the asylum seeker is unrepresented, particularly where the person is a minor or otherwise incapable of understanding the process. In such cases, AOs could evaluate the application and determine whether additional evidence is needed. While they may not be able to provide legal advice, the AOs could help develop the case by obtaining testimony, requesting evidence, and examining legal issues. At a minimum, such an evaluation would set the stage for a more efficient and more fair hearing in Immigration Court.

AOs can assist in other ways as well. If the AO determines that a case would likely not qualify for protection, they can inform the applicant, who may then choose to seek dismissal based on prosecutorial discretion, or perhaps leave the U.S. When asylum seekers have a better idea about their likelihood of success, they can make more informed decisions, which ultimately helps them and "the system."

If AOs were available to deal with resolvable applications, DHS attorneys could spend more time prepping their cases, communicating with opposing counsel, narrowing issues, and evaluating requests for prosecutorial discretion. As things stand now, DHS attorneys usually do not have much time for these tasks. If they had some help, they could do more work prior to trial, which would make the entire system more efficient.

Finally, moving AOs to DHS-OPLA and eliminating the Asylum Office would address a long-standing concern of asylum critics--that applicants currently receive "two bites at the apple." If the case is denied at the Asylum Office, the applicant can try again with the Immigration Court. While I do not find this critique entirely fair, it is not entirely false either. It seems to me that due process can be preserved if the two systems were combined, and efficiency would increase.

There is no shame in admitting that the affirmative asylum system is not working. Indeed, a recent report from the DHS Office of the Inspector General reaches this same conclusion. The question now is what to do about it: Continue on the same path or try something new? I believe we can improve and save our asylum system. I also believe that that system is well worth saving. We just need the will and the imagination to get it done.

Originally posted on the Asylumist: www.Asylumist.com