In January 2023, Customs and Border Protection launched a new iteration of its CBP One app. When it functions, the app allows migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border to make an appointment to present an initial request for asylum in the United States. The app has been plagued with technical problems, and many migrants simply did not have the equipment, language skills or know-how to use it properly. Nevertheless, starting on May 11, 2023, any migrant who arrives at the border and does not use the app may be barred from asylum in the United States. There are exceptions to the rule and the legality of excluding asylum seekers who do not utilize CBP One has been challenged in court.
Today, we'll talk about CBP One and what can be done to overcome the asylum bar for people who failed to make an appointment using the app.
Let's start with the law. New rules created by the Biden Administration block certain noncitizens from asylum if they arrive at the U.S.-Mexico border after having circumvented lawful pathways to the United States. The rules impose a "rebuttable presumption" of ineligibility for asylum for those who enter the United States from Mexico at the southwest land border without documents sufficient for lawful admission as described in INA § 212(a)(7). See 8 CFR § 208.33(a)(1). The rebuttable presumption applies to people who enter the U.S. between May 11, 2023 and May 11, 2025 and who pass through a third country, such as Mexico. See 8 CFR § 208.33(a)(1)(i) through (iii).
If you meet these conditions and did not use the CBP-One app to make an appointment when you arrived at the border, you may be barred from asylum. There are exceptions to this rule and if you demonstrate an exception, you can still qualify for asylum (i.e., the presumption that you are not eligible for asylum can be rebutted).
One exception is for unaccompanied children, as defined in 6 U.S.C.§ 279(g)(2). Children who enter the United States when they are less than 18 years old and who do not have a parent or legal guardian in the U.S. are not blocked from asylum if they fail to use CBP-One.
A second exception applies where “it was not possible to access or use the DHS scheduling system due to language barrier, illiteracy, significant technical failure, or other ongoing and serious obstacle.” See 8 CFR § 208.33(a)(2)(B). There have been numerous reports about how the CBP-One app does not function properly. If you are unable to make an appointment due to technical or other reasons, try to get evidence about that: Screen shots of error messages, emails seeking assistance, letters from people who know about the problems. The app is available only in English and Spanish, and so if you do not speak one of those languages that might also be a reason why you could not access the app (though how you are reading this blog post, I do not know).
Another exception is where the noncitizen faces “an imminent and extreme threat to life or safety, such as an imminent threat of rape, kidnapping, torture, or murder.” See 8 CFR § 208.33(a)(3)(B). The situation at the U.S.-Mexico border is dangerous, and you can certainly submit evidence about that. Also, if you have been threatened or harmed, or suffered a serious health issues at the border, you can get evidence about those problems as well.
There is also a family unity exception. If the principal applicant would qualify for asylum, but dependent applicants would not be independently eligible, or there are dependent family members that could follow to join the principal if asylum were granted, the presumption is "deemed rebutted as an exceptionally compelling circumstance" and the principal could receive asylum. See 8 CFR 1208.33(c).
Aside from these exceptions, there may be other bases to overcome the asylum bar. In one of my cases, a family of four was denied asylum for failing to utilize CBP One. They each received Withholding of Removal instead, which is not nearly as good. For the children, who were both under age 10 when they entered, I argued that they did not have the capacity to schedule a CBP One appointment, and that they should not be penalized just because their parents failed to qualify for an exception to the rule. In our case, the family is Uyghur, and since the government of China subjects Uyghurs to genocide and crimes against humanity, each family member was independently eligible for asylum, and so the family unity exception did not apply. While the judge rejected my argument, we have appealed, and we will see whether the Board of Immigration Appeals reaches a different conclusion. Given each individual's due process right to apply for asylum, we may yet have a chance.
In my case, we also argued that the asylum bar was unlawful. A recent Supreme Court case held that courts are not required to defer to an agency interpretation of the law where a statute is ambiguous. See Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, No. 22-451 (June 28, 2024). In our case, the statute related to asylum is not ambiguous. On the contrary, it is quite clear: "Any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States (whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including an alien who is brought to the United States after having been interdicted in international or United States waters), irrespective of such alien’s status, may apply for asylum…." See INA § 208(a)(1). Given that noncitizens have an absolute right to apply for asylum under the law, we argued that the government does not have the legal authority to impose restrictions to block would-be asylum seekers.
Finally, a number of immigrant rights organizations have challenged the validity of the CBP One limitations in court. How these lawsuits will ultimately play out, we do not know, but they could certainly result in changes to the current rules.
For purposes of an asylum case, it is obviously better to comply with the "circumvention of lawful pathways" rule. But if you failed to utilize the CBP One app and you are already in the U.S., you can potentially overcome the asylum bar with sufficient evidence and testimony.
Originally posted on the Asylumist: www.Asylumist.com
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
No CBP One = No Asylum?
Collapse
