Congress has debated whether undocumented immigrants deserve legalization for nearly 40 years. That debate has gone nowhere because it is asking the wrong questions. Congress should instead be asking how to create a legalization program for undocumented immigrants who meet the nation’s needs.

A national-interest legalization program would provide lawful status for needed immigrants, but it would not have to provide lawful permanent resident status or a pathway to citizenship. The foreign workers in question would just need lawful status, permitting them to live and work in the U.S.
The last major legalization program was established by the Immigration Reform and Control Act in 1986. It was supposed to legalize undocumented immigrants who had lived here for more than five years and met the act’s other eligibility requirements, in return for establishing enforcement measures that would prevent new undocumented immigrants from taking their place.

The legalization program granted lawful status to nearly 2.7 million undocumented immigrants, but the enforcement measures were not fully implemented. By the beginning of 1997, those 2.7 million immigrants who had been legalized were replaced entirely by a new group of undocumented immigrants.

One expert on immigration issues summed up the Republican reaction to this failure when he said, “Enforcement has to come first … or it will never happen.” This can be done without delaying implementation of the legalization program. Simply use enforcement measures set forth in self-executing statutory provisions instead of using provisions that require implementation to become effective.

A national-interest legalization program should include, first, eligibility based on national needs. Applicants for lawful status on the basis of the 1986 law’s five-year residency program also had to establish that their presence during that period was unlawful, but that they were otherwise admissible.

The Dignity Act of 2025 provides a more recent example of legalization eligibility requirements. Applicants would have to establish that they have been physically present in the U.S. since before Dec. 31, 2020, and they also must make $7,000 in restitution payments.

Congress should be basing legalization eligibility on what the country would gain from allowing particular undocumented immigrants to live and work lawfully in the U.S. This would make legalization a national-interest tool, not a gift.
The advocates of the legalization bills that have been rejected for the last 40 years claim that the undocumented aliens their bills would legalize are providing important benefits to the country. For instance, the American Immigration Council claims that “Undocumented immigrants are essential contributors to the economy. In 2023, undocumented immigrant households paid $89.8 billion in federal, state, and local taxes and held $299 billion in spending power.”

Those economic contributions are important, but they can’t be attributed to every undocumented immigrant in the U.S. Congress should limit legalization to undocumented immigrants who are making the claimed essential contributions to the economy or providing other needed benefits, such as military service; doctors and nurses for medically underserved areas; teachers for schools that have teaching shortages; or helping criminals with their rehabilitation efforts.

Under the 1986 law, legalization was implemented immediately, but the enforcement measures, such as employer sanctions, were only partially implemented. Congress never established a verification system that would make it possible for employers to quickly determine whether an immigrant has work authorization; this was needed to successfully implement a major nationwide employer sanctions program. Congress is still considering legislation to establish electronic verification of employment authorization.
Self-executing, statutory enforcement provisions would eliminate the implementation problem. This would include provisions such as increasing carrier fines for bringing immigrants to the U.S. without required visas; increasing penalties for immigrant smuggling and other criminal offenses in the Immigration and Nationality Act; and modification of the trafficking act’s provisions that are encouraging parents to send their children here in the care of professional smugglers, which exposes them to unacceptable risks.

It must also be noted that legalization does not have to be an all-or-nothing question.

Millions of immigrants who came to the U.S. lawfully spent years waiting for a visa to become available, paid application fees, submitted to medical screenings, and had in-person interviews. According to the Federation for American Immigration Reform, “Illegal immigration makes a mockery of their adherence to the rules, unfairly ‘cutting the line’ and requiring the government to expend its resources on illegal immigrants rather than on those lawfully seeking admission.”

Legalization based on national-interest status could acknowledge this difference with restricted benefits. Legalization would just permit recipients to live and work in the U.S. without fear of deportation — not with hope of gaining citizenship.

A national-interest legalization program, combined with self-executing enforcement provisions, isn’t an ideal solution, but it has a much greater chance of being enacted than any other version of immigration reform. The alternative is to continue the futile debate that has been going on for the last 40 years.

Read more at: https://thehill.com/opinion/immigrat...ation-program/


Published originally on The Hill.

Nolan Rappaport was detailed to the House Judiciary Committee as an executive branch immigration law expert for three years. He subsequently served as an immigration counsel for the Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security and Claims for four years. Prior to working on the Judiciary Committee, he wrote decisions for the Board of Immigration Appeals for 20 years. Follow his blog at https://nolanrappaport.blogspot.com.