On July 15, the Department of Justice filed an application asking the Alien Terrorist Removal Court to authorize proceedings against an unnamed alien suspected of being a terrorist. Although the court was established in 1996, by the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act, this was the first attempt to use it.
If successful, this could turn the lifeless “zombie” court into a powerful tool for deporting alien terrorists.
At a preliminary hearing the next day, Chief Judge Joan Ericksen expressed concern about the alleged connection between the alien’s conduct and the statutory provisions that were the basis for the application. She gave the government an opportunity to supplement its application. The government filed the supplement on July 22.
According to Section 401 of the law’s conference report, alien terrorists are “able to exploit many of the substantive and procedural provisions available to all deportable aliens in order to delay their removal from the U.S.” The Alien Terrorist Removal Court has “special procedures to ensure that aliens within the United States whom the government believes to be engaging in terrorist activity can be removed from the United States without disclosing” classified information.
According to the 9/11 Commission staff’s 9/11 Terrorist Travel report, which was issued in 2004, a major reason for not using Alien Terrorist Removal Court proceedings was that new immigration laws permitted classified evidence in traditional deportation hearings, making the special court unnecessary.
Immigration law expert Andrew R. Arthur says he was able to prosecute alien terrorist cases in immigration court removal proceedings when he was a government trial attorney. Now, ICE attorneys can submit classified information to immigration judges in removal proceedings for ex parte consideration or not in open court — “in the immigration judge’s chambers or a closed setting.”
The Trump administration issued guidelines on the use of classified information in immigration removal proceedings last September. And Chief U.S. District Judge James Boasberg in Washington, D.C., suggested using the Alien Terrorist Removal Court when he was questioning the administration’s use of the Alien Enemies Act. He pointed out that Congress established the court for handling terrorism-based removal proceedings.
Hans von Spakovsky, a senior fellow at Advancing American Freedom, says it was “a sign of negligence” that prior presidents did not use this court’s proceedings, which were established by Congress to facilitate quick removal of alien terrorists.
Statutory provisions include the following special procedures for the court:
The attorney general or the deputy attorney general must certify that the government’s application for an Alien Terrorist Removal Court hearing establishes probable cause that the person who is the subject of the application is an alien terrorist and that proceeding under ordinary immigration law would pose a national-security risk.
Ordinarily, the government is required to provide an unclassified summary of the classified information it intends to use in the proceedings that is sufficient to enable the alien who is the subject of the proceedings to prepare a defense.
The decision in Alien Terrorist Removal Court proceedings is made by one of five U.S. district judges designated by the chief justice of the United States.
Aliens in immigration removal proceedings have a right to be represented by counsel, but it must be at their own expense. In Alien Terrorist Removal Court proceedings, an attorney will be appointed at government expense if the alien is unable to afford one.
In immigration removal proceedings, the government must prove deportability of aliens who have been admitted to the United States by clear and convincing evidence. In Alien Terrorist Removal Court proceedings, the government just has to establish with a preponderance of the evidence that the alien is removable as an alien terrorist.
An alien in these proceedings has no right to ancillary relief. The judge cannot grant asylum, statutory withholding, cancellation, voluntary departure, adjustment, or registry. This produces a focused determination of terrorist removability.
Either party may appeal the court’s decision to the D.C. Circuit, and the circuit court judge must issue a decision within 60 days.
If deportation is ordered, detention is mandatory pending any appeal and removal.
Congress included safeguards to protect the rights of aliens subject to these proceedings, but they generally will be prohibited from seeing the classified information that is the basis for the proceedings or its source. They have to make their defense on the basis of an unclassified summary.
Therefore, Alien Terrorist Removal Court proceedings should be limited to cases involving classified information that cannot be protected adequately in removal proceedings before an immigration judge. This is especially important with top-secret information, the unauthorized release of which can reasonably be expected to result in “exceptionally grave damage to the national security.”
Read more at: https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciar...-court-zombie/
Published originally on The Hill.
Nolan Rappaport was detailed to the House Judiciary Committee as an executive branch immigration law expert for three years. He subsequently served as an immigration counsel for the Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security and Claims for four years. Prior to working on the Judiciary Committee, he wrote decisions for the Board of Immigration Appeals for 20 years.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Can Trump Use a ‘Zombie Court’ to Deport Suspected Terrorists? by Nolan Rappaport
Collapse
X
Collapse
-
Can Trump Use a ‘Zombie Court’ to Deport Suspected Terrorists? by Nolan Rappaport
Last edited by ImmigrationLawBlogs; 10-27-2026, 08:01 AM.Tags: None
You must be logged in to post a comment.
