© Getty Images
Democrats are demanding a bill to save 790,000 DACA participants who are facing uncertainty about whether their program will be allowed to continue, and have threatened to block passage of a funding bill needed to prevent a partial government shutdown if their demand is not met. The deadline for the funding bill is Jan. 19.
DACA provides temporary legal status and work authorization to certain aliens who were brought to the United States illegally by their parents.
Republicans have introduced a DACA bill, the Securing America's Future Act (H.R. 4760), but the ACLU may be right in describing it as a “collection of hard line provisions designed to sabotage, rather than advance, the possibility of a bipartisan breakthrough.”
Highlights from this 414-page bill:
Legal immigration
- End the Diversity Visa Program
- End chain migration
- Reduce legal immigration levels by about 25 percent
Border security
- Authorize President Trump’s wall
- Hire 5,000 Border Patrol Agents and 5,000 CBP Officers
- Expand the use of the National Guard
- Establish an entry-exit system at all ports of entry.
Prevent future illegal immigration
- Make E-Verify mandatory
- Crack down on sanctuary cities
- Enhance penalties for deported criminal aliens who return illegally
- Make illegal presence a federal misdemeanor
- Authorize quick return of unaccompanied alien minors apprehended at the border
DACA
- Provide temporary legal status for the 790,000 DACA participants that would have to be renewed every three years
The Republicans want these measures to prevent a repeat of what happened the last time they agreed to a major legalization program. The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 legalized 2.7 million people in the late 1980s and early 1990s, but by October 1996, the undocumented alien population had reached 5 million and was growing at an average annual rate of 275,000. The enforcement measures that were supposed to prevent illegal immigration in the future were not implemented.
Read more at http://thehill.com/opinion/immigrati...a-winning-plan
Published originally on the Hill.
About the author. Nolan Rappaport was detailed to the House Judiciary Committee as an executive branch immigration law expert for three years; he subsequently served as an immigration counsel for the Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security and Claims for four years. Prior to working on the Judiciary Committee, he wrote decisions for the Board of Immigration Appeals for 20 years.

"These allegations raise a plausible inference that racial animus was a motivating factor in the decision to end DACA."
This indicates that Muslim Ban litigation is not the only instance in which federal judges are beginning to determine that various immigration initiatives by the Trump administration are motivated by racial or religious animosity.
https://www.politico.com/story/2018/01/12/trump-racism-daca-dreamers-judge-339512
In reality, there is a strong factual case to be made that ALL, or nearly all, of Trump's immigration actions as president are motivated by racial and religious "animus", and that Trump's latest outrage against African and Haitian immigrants is part of a pattern of hatred against non-white immigrants dating from his vicious attack against Mexican "criminals" and "rapists" and call for a worldwide Muslim ban as a presidenial candidate up to now - not just an isolated "foolish" comment, as Nolan contends above.-
In the same way, as I will show further in my own blog comment (along with the three ilw.com blog comments of my own which I have already written about Trump's racist 'shithole' remarks!), Trump's statement that America needs immigrants from Norway more than from Africa and Haiti is unlikely to help him in future litigation concerning his mass exclusion, mass deportation, agenda.
The title of Nolan's article suggests that Trump has a "winning plan" on DACA.
If he does, it must be something other than calling Latino immigrants "criminals' and 'rapists' , shouting that 'Islam hates us' and accusing black immigrants of coming from 'shithole' countries and preferring white-skinned immigrants from Scandinavia instead.
That is not a "winning plan" , and let us hope that the president comes to realize that one day, sooner rather than later.
Roger Algase
Attorney at Law
Nolan Rappaport
My last "outburst" consisted of quoting from and commenting on a decision of a federal judge only days ago ruling that Trump's DACA termination was illegal, in part because of evidence that it was motivated by racial animus against minority immigrants, and comparing that with earlier court decisions invalidating Trump's Muslim ban orders.
Were those court decisions merely "outbursts" too?
There was once a time when quoting from and commenting on judicial decisions was called "legal discussion", not an "outburst".
The same applies to my comments on a number of points that Nolan has raised in his own article. This also used to be called "legal discussion" once upon a time.
Today, January 15, we celebrate the birthday of Martin Luther King Jr., one of the greatest Americans of all time, who, 55 years ago, in 1963, made an immortal speech containing the words "I Have a Dream", and whose legacy Donald Trump himself paid homage to in January 12 statement that upheld the equality of all people regardless of country of birth and directly contradicted his statement the day before that African and Haitian immigrants were inferior to immigrants from Norway.
As a young Harvard Law School graduate, I had the great honor and privilege of working for a distinguished lawyer and close friend and adviser to Dr. King, Clarence B. Jones, who was representing Dr. King in federal copyright litigation involving the "I Have a Dream" speech. I played a small but not totally insignificant role in helping prepare the paperwork for that litigation - including copyrighting the speech itself.
I can still remember that time, when Dr. King himself was denounced by his segregationist opponents as a "demagogue" and a "rabble-rouser" and was falsely accused of having Communist sympathies, before finally being assassinated because of his support of equal rights for black people.
As we honor Dr. King's legacy today, we should also be saddened by the fact that we now have a president who, only one day before honoring that legacy himself, stated, according to at least one highly respected US Senator who was present, that America doesn't want immigrants from "shithole" parts of the world where people have the same skin color as Dr. King.
I trust that Nolan, in keeping with his own distinguished reputation as a respected legal scholar and immigration law authority, will not try to dismiss my comments about my experience working on behalf of Dr. King, however small and brief, and how this experience relates to immigration issues today, as a mere "outburst."
Roger Algase
Attorney at Law