In an eloquent rebuke to the calls to exclude Muslim immigrants from the US for no other reason than that their religion has become the target of demagogic politicians and therefore unpopular with some of the US public, Massachusetts Chief Justice Ralph D. Gants, who is Jewish, strongly condemned bigotry and Islamophobia in a speech at his state's largest mosque following Friday prayers on December 18.
Speaking at the Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center, Chief Justice Gants first referred to the Jewish tradition of acceptance of foreigners, while recalling the Jewish immigrant experience in America:
"The Old Testament many times reminds us: 'Once we were strangers in the land of Egypt, and that line is the centerpiece of the Jewish holiday of Passover. I think of that phrase often, because I know that my forefathers were once strangers in the land of the United States. as were the forefathers of nearly all of us, and many of us were not so welcome here."
Chief Justice Gants then spoke about America's history of prejudice against refugees and other immigrants from many different countries:
"In the 1840's and early 1850's, this country was not so welcoming to the influx of Irish Catholics fleeing the potato famine in Ireland...
For nearly a century, until 1965, our immigration laws were designed to prevent Chinese and Japanese from entering this country."
He continued:
"During the Great Depression, Mexican-Americans were scapegoated for the economic deprivation they did not cause, and more than two million were deported to Mexico. By some estimates, more than half were born in the United States and were therefore US citizens."
After also referring to America's history of discrimination against Italian-Americans, German-Americans, Japanese-Americans and, last but not least, African-Americans, Chief Justice Gants pointed out:
"If you add up all those who are Irish -Americans, Italian-Americans, German-Americans, Asian-Americans, Mexican-Americans, African-Americans, Jewish-Americans, all of those who were once strangers in the land of Egypt, you end up with the vast majority of this nation."
Chief Justice Gants then concluded:
"So I hold firm in the hope that, if we remember who we are and where we came from and what we once endured, if we remember that we, too, were once strangers in the land of Egypt, the vast majority of Americans will stand arm-in-arm with Muslim-Americans and together, we will get past these troubling times."
And finally, in a reminder that the rule of law Trumps the rule of hate and prejudice, he stated:
And until that happens, we still have our Constitution and our rule of law to protect us, and lawyers, prosecutors and judges prepared to apply those laws to ensure our rights."
For many of our politicians, pundits and media figures this holiday season has become the season of Donald Trump and other public figures who are either trying to stir up hatred against Muslims and other unpopular immigrant minorities, or who are too timid to oppose it.
But for those who truly understand what America means, as well as the Jewish tradition and this Christmas day itself, this season will be remembered as the season of Chief Justice Ralph D. Gants of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts.
To read more about Chief Justice Gant's appearance at the mosque, and for a link to the full text of his speech, go to:
http://huffingtonpost.com/entry/ralp...b06fa6887e755d
______________________________
Roger Algase is a New York immigration lawyer and a graduate of Harvard College and Harvard Law School, both of which Justice Gants also attended.
For more than 35 years, Roger has been helping mainly skilled and professional immigrants, from many different parts of the world and ethnic/religious backgrounds, obtain work visas and green cards. His email address is algaselex@gmail.com
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Mass. Chief Justice: Law Trumps Bigotry Against Muslim Immigrants. By Roger Algase
Collapse
X
Collapse
Nolan is also correct in pointing out that "alien" is used in our immigration law. It is in fact a key term in the INA, used again and again. It should be removed from the law and replaced by a less pejorative term, of which there are many available, such as, for example the simple and commonly used words "foreigner", "foreign person", or 'non-US citizen".
Nolan is also fond of the phrase argumentum ad hominem.
I admire his use of Latin. I am fond of using Latin phrases myself. One of my favorites is the phrase that Virgil, in Book 1 of the Aeneid , puts in the mouth of the legendary Queen Dido of Carthage:
"Tros Tyriusque mihi nullo discrimine agetur"
This phrase can be translated as:
"I make no distinction between an immigrant [Trojan] and a citizen [Tyrian or Carthagenian]."
To be fair, the above is more of an ideal, a recognition of common humanity and the right to equal justice under the law than it is a practical suggestion for drafting a 21st century immigration statute.
As Virgil also mentions in his great epic poem, Queen Dido's liberal views on immigration did not prevent her from relying on border guards to protect the security of her realm.
Roger Algase
Attorney at Law
All one needs to do is change a few words and phrases here and there, and Winslow's diatribe could just as easily have been copied from similar attacks against Jewish and Catholic immigrants at various times in America's past by anti-Semites, Know-Nothings and various other assorted xenophobic and nativist groups.
As Polybius writes in Book 1 of his Histories (Loeb Classical Library translation, 2010):
"...the soundest education and training for a life of active politics is the study of History..."
Chief Justice Gants, in his remarks, shows a knowledge and appreciation of America's all too extensive history of bigotry, fear and discrimination against a long list of unpopular ethnic or religious immigrant groups.
Donald Trump and today's other minority immigrant-haters seem to think that Muslims and Hispanics, their favorite targets du jour, are the only immigrants who have ever been regarded as dangerous or otherwise undesirable in America.
But as Chief Justice Gants points out, if one adds up the list of immigrants who have been attacked and regarded as unwelcome in America in the past, it would include the ancestors of nearly all of us who are fortunate enough to be able to call ourselves Americans today.
Roger Algase
Attorney at Law
Other showbox references:
showboxappandroid.com
showboxappapk.com