The Board of Immigration Appeals is leaning towards setting a precedent in Immigration
law that would eventually allow or prevent immigrants from seeking adjustment of status
based on same-sex marriage. Recently, three appeals and a motion to reopen were filed
with the BIA on behalf of same-sex married couples that duly registered their
relationships under state laws. In all four cases that originated in California,
Florida, New York and Pennsylvania, the BIA remanded the record to the relevant
District Director and Immigration judge for further proceedings.  In the meantime the
BIA refused to take a position on the constitutionality of DOMA due to lack of

The facts of the cases are identical. The petitioners filed the I-130visa petitions on
behalf of the same-sex spouses. Three marriages were concluded in the states that allow
gay marriages, and in one instance, the couple got married in Ontario, Canada, and was
subsequently granted domestic partnership (2004) and civil union status (2007) in the
state of New Jersey.

As it could be expected, the petitions were denied based on the section3 (a) of the
Defense of Marriage Act, Pub. L. No. 104-199, 110 Stat. 2149(1996) (DOMA).District
Directors (in denials) and DHS (in the opposition to the motion to reopen) argued that
the marriages and one civil union between the petitioners and beneficiaries were not
valid relationships for the purposes of Federal law pursuant to the section 3 (a) of
DOMA. The petitioners filed a motion to reopen and appeals with the BIA. The BIA agreed
and remanded the records for further proceedings ordering the parties to address the
following issues:

1)     Whether the petitioner and the beneficiary have a valid marriage under the state
        laws; and

2)     Whether, absent the requirement of section 3 of DOMA, the marriage of the
        petitioner and the beneficiary would qualify the beneficiary to be considered a
        "spouse" under the Immigration and Nationality Act.

Clearly, those remands are uncommon. They are an effort by the BIA indicating
responsiveness to the current society demands and changes. Hopefully, they can grow into
a landmark decision granting relief to deserving individuals.

image source

Attached Files