Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Legacy on Immigration


Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a fierce champion of progressive rights and the second woman to serve as a Supreme Court Justice, died on Sept. 18, 2020. Long recognized as a staunch advocate for women’s rights, Justice Ginsburg leaves behind a legacy on immigration that shows her vision for justice did not end with her work on gender equality.

Her voice on the Supreme Court consistently and relentlessly defended the rights of those denied legal protections. She is known for her work on gender discrimination, equal pay, and reproductive justice issues. But equally important are the positions she took in several landmark immigration cases.

Justice Ginsburg’s positions on immigration had a lasting impact. She:

  • Helped overturnthe Trump administration’s decision to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) initiative.
  • Blocked an Arizona lawthat made undocumented status a state crime and required state police officers to check the immigration status of any person in their custody before releasing them. The law also allowed state officers to detain anyone they suspected of undocumented status.
  • Upheldthe constitutional right of noncitizens to challenge their detention in government custody.
  • Defended placing limitations on prolonged immigration detention by:
    • Joiningthe majority to prohibit the indefinite detention of immigrants subject to deportation who could not be sent back to their country of origin.
    • Dissentingto a majority opinion that allowed certain immigrants to be held in lengthy, mandatory detention.
    • Dissentingto a majority opinion that found immigrants in prolonged detention had no right to regular bond hearings.

Ginsburg’s work on immigration highlights her commitment to the American value of fundamental fairness. And she never gave in, even when her opinions were not in the majority. Justice Ginsburg instead reminds us about “the dissenter’s hope: that they are writing not for today, but for tomorrow.”

Her perspective will be greatly missed on the Supreme Court bench and in our society. But our country will feel her legacy for decades to come. She will continue to inspire people to fight for justice and—by following her lead—may make some of her dissents the law of tomorrow.

May her memory always be a blessing and a reminder of benevolence.


This post originally appeared on Immigration Impact. Reprinted with permission.

About The Author

Eshani Pandya and Caroline Walters work for American Immigration Council.

The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.