EB-5 Regional Center Termination Overturned: AAO Gets it Right


In a huge win for EB-5 regional centers, the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (“AAO”) overturned a previous regional center termination order by the Immigrant Investor Program Office (“IPO”) in Matter of P-A-S-, LLC, ID# 513109 (AAO Dec. 21, 2017) . This is the first time the AAO has overruled the IPO since creating the new standard for EB-5 regional center terminations articulated in Matter of S-D-R-C-, ID# 13768 (AAO Mar. 15, 2017) .

In the non-precedent decision, the AAO issued a thorough and balanced analysis of the negative and positive factors for EB-5 regional center authorization. This decision provides a particularly just outcome for the EB-5 investors, since all I-526 petitions would have been denied if the regional center’s termination had been sustained. Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP has previously written on the types of “positive and negative indicators” that IPO is to balance when determining whether an EB-5 regional center is continuing to promote economic growth in accordance with 8 C.F.R. § 204.6(m)(6).

The EB-5 regional center in this decision, Path America SnoCo LLC, was first designated in August 2011. In August 2015, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) filed a complaint in federal court alleging that the former principal of the EB-5 regional Center fraudulently raised EB-5 capital and misappropriated investors’ funds for other projects or his personal use. As part of the SEC litigation, a court-appointed receiver took possession and control of the regional center’s projects in October 2015. Due to the SEC allegations, IPO terminated its regional center designation in November 2016 for failure to promote economic growth.

On appeal, the regional center provided documentation from federal court and the receiver indicating that the former principal accused of stealing the money is no longer a principal of the regional center and no longer controls its activity or EB-5 investor funds. The regional center provided evidence of positive steps it took to overcome the diversion of EB-5 investor funds and to rectify the lack of procedural safeguards that allowed this to occur, including a new management company to run the regional center’s operations. The regional center also presented evidence to show that the sponsored EB-5 project continued to make significant progress on construction before and during the SEC proceedings, and included evidence that the project was operational and creating jobs. These positive factors outweighed the negative factors related to the diversion of funds, mismanagement, and lack of monitoring safeguards.

EB-5 regional centers struggling with a dreaded Notice of Intent to Terminate (“NOIT”) should look to this pivotal decision with cautious optimism. While it may be difficult to acquire traditional financing while under SEC investigation for budgetary shortfalls, and to recover misappropriated funds, the AAO appears to be looking more at the “whole picture” surrounding the regional center’s termination to determine whether it is more likely than not to promote economic growth in the future.

Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP is a full-service immigration law firm known worldwide for its unmatched excellence in providing top-quality U.S. immigration representation. Subscribe to our immigration blog to remain updated and contact Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP Immigration Law offices if you have any questions. We have Immigration Law Offices in New York and Los Angeles .

This post originally appeared on Wolfsdorf Immigration Law Group. Copyright © 2017 Wolfsdorf Connect - All Rights Reserved.

About The Author

Bernard Wolfsdorf Bernard Wolfsdorf is the managing partner of the top-rated law firm, Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP (www.wolfsdorf.com), and the past national president of the 14,000-member American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA). Established in 1986, Wolfsdorf Rosenthal LLP is known worldwide for providing exceptional quality legal services. With 19 lawyers and offices in Los Angles and New York, the firm was recently listed as a top-tier immigration practice by Chambers & Partners with several of the firm's attorneys listed in the 2015 International Who's Who Legal. Mr. Wolfsdorf specializes in EB-5 investment immigration in addition to the full range of global immigration matters. Robert Blanco specializes in business and employment immigration cases. He prepares both immigrant and non-immigrant petitions for skilled workers, executive managers, high net worth investors, and people of extraordinary ability in the arts, sciences, and business. As a member of the firm’s EB-5 team, Mr. Blanco prepares cases for individual investors and advises U.S. businesses on how to structure investment projects under the regulations of the EB-5 program. He also represents clients before the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). Mr. Blanco graduated cum laude with a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration from the McDonough School of Business at Georgetown University. He earned his Juris Doctor degree from Loyola Law School with a concentration in Corporate Law. Mr. Blanco is admitted to practice law in the state of California. Joseph Barnett is licensed as an attorney in the State of Illinois and the State of Wisconsin and practices exclusively in immigration and nationality law. Mr. Barnett represents immigrant investors seeking permanent residency in the United States through USCIS-designated Regional Centers and investment in their own businesses. Mr. Barnett also assists developers with the establishment of complex corporate and financing structures for EB-5 capital. He works with economists, securities lawyers, business plan writers, and other professionals to prepare Regional Center applications, amendments, and project “exemplar” approvals.

The opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of ILW.COM.