His baby face is wan, his eyes sleepless. His dark hair has turned gray in jail. Macan Singh, 33 -- just released from 16 months of Immigration and Naturalization Service detention -- hardly looked like the symbol of an increasingly complex debate on immigration in this country. But he is.
No question -- Singh is an illegal immigrant and will be deported back to India. But his case is instructive because it reflects a clash of governmental objectives -- the enforcement of immigration law versus the protection of exploited workers.
Singh was jailed by the INS after his former boss, a Bay Area businessman, Charanjit Jutla, also his uncle, allegedly reported him to the agency in retaliation -- one day after settling Singh's claim for nearly three years of unpaid wages for work that, Singh's lawyers alleged, resembled "involuntary servitude."
According to court documents, Jutla allegedly "recruited" Singh fraudulently to come to the United States in 1995 by promising him an education, housing and a future business partnership. Jutla's company, C.D. & R's Oil Inc., owns several gas stations and truck stops in Albany, Union City and Tracy. Singh did live with Jutla's family in Fremont, where he was fed and shared a room with two other relatives who also worked for Jutla. But he allegedly was never paid a penny for the 84-hour weeks he worked at the gas stations and at home, where he was a servant. When Singh asked for money in early 1998, Jutla allegedly fired him.
Jutla's lawyer, Eugene Franklin, said neither he nor his client would comment. Jutla has denied Singh's allegations in court and before state Labor Commission hearing officer Ellen Shaffer. Jutla and his wife, Davinder, testified before Shaffer that Singh lived with them as a relative and "spent time" at the gas stations. But, they said, he never did work because he was not "legally authorized" to do so in the United States.
<me>
Posted
I tell you - don't work for Indian and Chinese immigrant business owners. They think that they are back in their home country. Treating people like slaves. They just don't have a heart. Don't buy from their restaurants and groceries. Don't stay in roach-infested motels.
<Sam>
Posted
Don't don't buy gas from their service stations.
<Bushmaster>
Posted
They are everywhere, every single Seven Eleven and similar convenience store are managed by them... And Citgo gas stations... I wouldn't buy from Citgo anyway...
<USC>
Posted
You people know According to recent survey 80% motels of U S are owned by INDIANS.All this happened in last 20 years How did it happen? whom to blame?OUR IMMIGRATION POLICY These people came as atomic chain reaction ,known as PATELS ,They are not a part of us never will be. They employ their own people ,American lost all their business.