Comment: China is 3rd India is 1st

EB5 Market Update - October 2018
Table of Contents
(1) China is in 3rd place! - a new 4-tier global EB5 market
(2) Smaller raises + Higher marketing costs >>> LoRiskLoReward changes to MedRiskMedReward
(3) B2B vs B2C
(4) India - a tale of 2 markets

(1) China is in 3rd place! - a new 4-tier global EB5 market
As of September 2018, China is in 3rd place in terms of actual wires received by EB5 issuers during that month. India is the new numero uno EB5 country, followed by Vietnam. Here is the outlook for the next 12 months, in terms of annual wires the EB5 world is now stratified into four tiers:
TIER ONE: 1000 to 2000 wires :: India, all by itself
TIER TWO: 300 to 600 wires each :: Vietnam, China, Korea, Brazil
TIER THREE: 100 to 200 wires each :: Taiwan, South Africa, Mexico, Russia, Turkey
TIER FOUR: most are less than 50 wires :: all other countries

(2) Smaller raises + Higher marketing costs >>> LoRiskLoReward changes to MedRiskMedReward
Today's EB5 capital market is less than half the size of the market of 2015/2016, and is also splintered over many countries. Consequently, planned raises today are much smaller (much less than 100 investors), and marketing costs much higher than 2015/2016, and even more so, when a higher marketing cost is spread over a smaller raise. This additional cost is not sustainable in the USA's efficient real estate financing markets, and move the EB5 market away from traditional EB5 players toward new players - in effect, the market is moving from developers with low mezzanine finance costs toward developers with high mezzanine finance costs. Those with high mezzanine finance costs find the additional EB5 marketing costs still result in EB5 capital which is very competitive, whereas those developers with low mezzanine finance costs cannot justify the high marketing costs needed in today's EB5 world. Furthermore, Indian investors are favoring issuers with higher returns, such as 2% per annum and higher (in effect, the points that used to go to Chinese agents now go to Indian investors). What all this does is to move the market away from a low risk, low reward model toward a medium risk, medium reward model. Many EB5 market players of 2015/2016 will not make the transition to the new EB5 world, and are either trying to complete their last EB5 raise now, or worse, are curtailing their final EB5 raise.

(3) B2B vs B2C
The China model, which is also followed in Taiwan, Vietnam and Korea, is an agent-intermediated one, in effect a B2B market where EB5 issuers do not have to deal with investors directly, and the risk of capital agglomeration is absorbed by a player other than the EB5 issuer. The India model, which is also followed in Brazil, South Africa, Mexico, Russia and Turkey, does not feature "agents", these in effect are B2C markets where EB5 issuers frequently engage investors face-to-face, and the risk of capital agglomeration is largely on the shoulders of the EB5 issuer. Apart from this cost also making for a move away from traditional EB5 players to new players, there is also the real issue of corporate culture - the corporate skill set for B2B is different from B2C, and this factor is also among the causes of many traditional EB5 market players wrapping up their final EB5 raise, or even abandoning ongoing raises. Of course, most traditional EB5 players will remain committed to EB5 capital in the form of re-deployed funds, but as far as new injections of EB5 capital, for many, their last hurrah was in early 2018.

(4) India - a tale of 2 markets
India is the new gorilla in town, but is actually two gorillas, in that the Indian market is actually two markets, each quite different from one another - the first being Indian EB5 investors in India, and the second being Indian EB5 investors in USA (there are also Indian investors in 3rd countries, but these are much fewer in number than is commonly believed). Apart from a different securities compliance regime, there are also other important differences in approaching these two markets. The EB5 market is currently in the process of major expansion, in terms of new EB5 capital inflows, after the nadir of April 2018 through September 2018. [For reasons we will go into in a later update, Indian EB5 capital flows will not be affected by retrogression for the foreseeable future. Further, any increases in investment amount will not change the 4-tier market described above, nor will increased investment amounts prevent the exit of traditional EB5 players in favor of newer, smaller, riskier, developers.] The EB5 market today is poised for explosive growth, but with many new players, stay tuned!

Article: “EB-5 Securities: New Developments And Updated NYU Stern Database – 2018 Edition” By Gary Friedland and Jeanne Calderon

Article: Expecting Asylum-Seekers to Become US Asylum Law Experts: Reflections on My Trip to the Folkston ICE Processing Center By Sophia Genovese

Article: What the Government Considers the US Border May Surprise You By Tory Johnson

Blogging: What Disclaimer? ~ USCIS Ignores Labor Department Warning That the Occupational Outlook Handbook Never Be Used for Legal Purposes By Angelo A. Paparelli

Blogging: Trump's demonizing of non-white immigrants is not just campaign talk, but actual policy, with dire consequences for legal immigration and the rule of law. Will the courts step in? By Roger Algase

News: OL Publishes Statistics on H-1Bs For FY2018 Quarter 4

News: DOL Publishes Statistics on PERMs For FY2018 Quarter 4

Focus: H1B to EB5

    Exhibition/speaking opportunities for November H-1B events are available. Please see below for our current H1B to EB5 Expo schedule:
    • Philadelphia, PA - Monday, October 22 ( SOLD OUT )
    • Dallas, TX - Wednesday, October 24 ( SOLD OUT )
    • San Francisco, CA - Friday, October 26 ( SOLD OUT )
    • Washington, DC - Monday, November 12 ( 2 Seats Available )
    • Atlanta, GA - Wednesday, November 14 ( 2 Seats Available )
    • San Jose, CA - Friday, November 16 ( SOLD OUT )
    • Boston, MA - Monday, November 26 ( 4 Seats Available )
    • Dallas, TX - Wednesday, November 28 ( 4 Seats Available )
    • Los Angeles, CA - Friday, November 30 ( 4 Seats Available )

    Half Day Event for Indian H-1Bs considering EB-5 Option (Speaking Opportunity included) Please bring brochures, PowerPoint presentation, table displays and business cards.
    Special Note for Attorneys: This event will feature two immigration attorney panels solely on immigration law matters. The only way an immigration attorney can participate and speak at this event is if they are nominated by an issuer who is exhibiting at the event (there is no fee charged to immigration attorneys).

    EB-5 Issuers only - $3,999 per city for H-1B Event
    (Inquire about Discounts and also about Platinum Level)

    For more info please call (212)545-0818 or email or click here.

    Headline: Castillo: Immigration attorney in ICE crosshairs over leaked memo Click here
    Headline: Trump urges Dems to help craft new immigration laws: ‘Chuck & Nancy, call me!' Click here
    Headline: Trump Administration Seeks DACA Immigration Ruling Soon Click here
    Headline: Trump's stance on migrant caravan could increase illegal immigration Click here
    Headline: ICE Removes Immigration Detainees From Federal Prisons, Including Washington; 3 Remain In Oregon Click here

    Help Wanted: Immigration Paralegal
    Ridgewood, NJ - Business immigration specialists wanted - Northern New Jersey office located in Ridgewood, NJ : International Law Firm with offices in NJ, NY, Indiana and Canada seeks Immigration Paralegals and Immigration Specialists for several new positions. Essential Duties and Responsibilities consist of preparation of a wide variety of business-based nonimmigrant petitions (H-1B, H-3, TN, E, J-1, L-1A/B and O-1). Assist with corporate clients with PERM application process. PERM process beginning to end a "must". Assist with applying for and obtaining work visas with U.S. consular offices abroad. Work closely with clients' and their employees and families to provide comprehensive immigration service through the application process, including responses to applications, Requests for Evidence, interviews and compliance. Compile and maintain records of immigration forms, other documentation and records of activity on behalf of corporate clients' employees. Review immigration regulations and be able to apply them to various case scenarios. Perform research using all available immigration research tools including government agencies' websites. Education and/or Experience: Required: BA/BS with strong academic credentials; Proficient at Microsoft Office Applications and Adobe Acrobat; Minimum of 1 to 4 years of experience with the corporate business immigration process. Preferred: Paralegal Certificate and Foreign Language. Other Skills and Abilities: Strong oral and written communication skills; Excellent attention to detail and proofreading skills; Strong sense of good judgment; Well-developed analytical and problem solving skills; A self-starter who desires to show ownership and commitment to the job. We sponsor. Salary commensurate with experience. To apply, please send cover letter and salary requirements to:

    Help Wanted: Immigration Attorney
    Chicago, Illinois - Sidley Austin seeks an experienced immigration lawyer to join the Chicago office as a staff attorney. Candidates should have a minimum of 2 years of experience in high volume immigration work; the ability to work an immigration case from beginning to end (various forms/filings); experience handling requests for evidence; strong legal research and writing skills; the ability to manage client relationships; and experience working with and supervising paralegals. Interested candidates should apply at:

    Help Wanted: Immigration Attorney
    Millburn, New Jersey - Dornbaum & Peregoy top rated Specialty Employment/Business/Immigration Law Practice; seeks attorney to perform exacting research, creation of sophisticated legal arguments, and preparation of detailed submissions to USCIS; USDOL; USDOS; and agencies on H-1, L-1, TN, J-1, E-1/E-2, O-1,EB-1, NIW, PERM and RFE responses. Complex, high volume caseload of employment based business immigration cases; for IT, pharmaceutical, medical devices and biotech; finance, energy, banking, education and emerging businesses. Requires detailed analysis of eligibility under alternate categories; preparation of clear, concise, well-written, persuasive submissions to secure work authorization or residence, and/or support and justify the relief sought. Must analyze statutes, regulations, memoranda, guidelines; prepare compelling legal documents for appropriate agency. Performing research as needed; writing a persuasive case to support the petition for the category sought. Work would also include advice and consultation to employers on a number of diverse employment matters, including hiring, termination, reorganization, retention, and regulatory compliance (I-9 audits; E-Verify and Wage and Hour issues). A background in corporate governance and/or tax is helpful to understand the corporate relationships that are the basis for some categories.Please email resume, and writing sample (preferable non-legal (an example of expository college writing/essay would be best)) and salary requirements to:

    Help Wanted: Immigration Attorney
    New Orleans, Louisiana - Reputable & fast-paced New Orleans law firm seeks FT, Spanish speaking Immigration Attorney to join our team. The firm offers a competitive package including paid holidays, paid vacation, and a retirement fund. Responsibilities include: Providing legal expertise for matters such as visa applications, green cards, citizenship and naturalization, deportation issues, and employment for non-citizens. Experience would include immigration trials, individual hearings for asylum, waiver experience, and cancellation of removal hearings. Ideally candidate will have 2+ years of Immigration experience, and can work with little supervision. Candidate must be fully bi-lingual and able to read, write, and speak in Spanish. Please do not apply if you do not speak fluent Spanish. to learn more about who we are. To apply please email:

    Help Wanted: Immigration Attorney
    Washington, DC - Small Washington, DC immigration law firm (Lichtman & Rosenblum, PLLC) seeks to hire a recent law graduate or attorney with up to three years of immigration experience for an Associate Attorney position. Solid academic record, demonstrated interest in immigration, excellent writing skills, and attention to detail are required. To apply, send cover letter, resume, writing sample, and law school transcript to with “Associate Attorney Position” in the subject line.

    Letters of the Week

    ComingsNGoings: Immigration Reading
    The Gift of Global Talent: How Migration Shapes Business, Economy & Society By William R. Kerr Stanford Business Books, 256 pages, $18.81

    An Important disclaimer! The information provided on this page is not legal advice. Transmission of this information is not intended to create, and receipt by you does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Readers must not act upon any information without first seeking advice from a qualified attorney. Copyright 1995-2017 American Immigration LLC, ILW.COM. Send correspondence and articles to Letters and articles may be edited and may be published and otherwise used in any medium. The views expressed in letters and articles do not necessarily represent the views of ILW.COM.
    Publisher: Sam Udani ISSN: 1930-062X
    Advisory Board: Jason Dzubow, Rami Fakhoury, Matthew Kolken, Chris Musillo, Lory Rosenberg, Greg Siskind, Joel Stewart, Margaret Wong